Try the clues before opening the answer

These examples were created for this page and are separate from the game’s 21 cases. Use only the facts printed in each puzzle. Exactly one of the three statements is false. Open the hint if you want a nudge, then open the explanation to check every statement.

You can read and solve these examples without JavaScript, a login, or a download. They do not record a score or change your saved game progress.

01 · Put the facts in order

Tickets at the bakery

Ava, Ben, and Cleo each hold one different queue ticket: 11, 12, or 13. Customers are served from the lowest number to the highest. Ava has ticket 12. Ben’s ticket is lower than Ava’s. Cleo’s ticket is higher than Ava’s.

  1. Ava: “Ben will be served before me.”
  2. Ben: “Cleo has the last ticket.”
  3. Cleo: “Ava will be served before Ben.”

Whose statement is false?

Show a hint

There is only one available ticket below 12 and one above it. Assign those numbers before comparing the statements.

Reveal the false statement and explanation

Cleo’s statement is false. Ben has 11, Ava has 12, and Cleo has 13. Ben goes first, then Ava, then Cleo.

Ava’s statement is true because 11 comes before 12. Ben’s is true because Cleo holds 13, the last of these three tickets. Cleo reverses the order of Ava and Ben, so her statement cannot fit the facts.

The useful habit: turn a verbal comparison into a concrete order. Once you have 11 → 12 → 13, the statements are easier to check.

The queue had one wild ambition: to become a conga line. The bakery declined.

02 · Combine two clues

The picnic cooler

A cooler has three compartments: top, middle, and bottom. Each contains exactly one kind of drink: juice, water, or tea. Juice is not in the middle. Tea is below juice. Water is not in the bottom.

  1. Jules: “The juice is below the tea.”
  2. Kai: “The water is in the middle.”
  3. Remy: “The tea is below the water.”

Whose statement is false?

Show a hint

Could juice be in the bottom if tea must be below it? Use that with the clue that rules out the middle.

Reveal the false statement and explanation

Jules’s statement is false. Juice cannot be in the middle, and it cannot be at the bottom because tea must be below it. That puts juice at the top. Water cannot be at the bottom, so it goes in the middle. Tea fills the bottom compartment.

The only arrangement that fits every clue
CompartmentDrink
TopJuice
MiddleWater
BottomTea

Jules puts juice below tea, which contradicts both the stated clue and the solved arrangement. Kai and Remy match that arrangement.

The useful habit: a clue that seems incomplete can become decisive when you combine it with another clue.

The tea asked for a promotion. Management said it was already steeping up.

03 · Check the overlap

Three library visits

The library’s entry log is accurate. Mira arrived at 10:05 and left at 10:12. Owen arrived at 10:09 and left at 10:16. Priya arrived at 10:14 and left at 10:20. Each person made just that one visit.

  1. Mira: “Owen arrived while I was there.”
  2. Owen: “All three of us were there at the same time.”
  3. Priya: “Owen was there when I arrived.”

Whose statement is false?

Show a hint

Owen overlaps with two different visits. Does that mean Mira and Priya overlap with each other?

Reveal the false statement and explanation

Owen’s statement is false. Mira and Owen were together from 10:09 until 10:12. Owen and Priya were together from 10:14 until 10:16. But Mira had already left two minutes before Priya arrived. There was no time when all three were present.

Mira’s claim fits Owen’s 10:09 arrival, and Priya’s fits Owen’s 10:16 departure. Owen’s two separate overlaps do not create a three-person overlap.

The useful habit: test an “all” claim against every person or condition. Two correct pairings do not automatically prove a larger group claim.

The library clock wanted a quiet job. It still got ticked off every second.

What to take into the game

Start by fixing an order or location when you can. Combine clues instead of treating each one in isolation. Be especially careful with broad claims such as “all,” “first,” and “at the same time.” You are looking for the statement the facts rule out, rather than the character with the most suspicious tone.

If you think an example allows another answer, send us the puzzle title and your reasoning. That gives us something specific to check and correct.

Put the method to work

The full collection has 21 cases, free hints, and a joke after each reveal.

Play the free game